Why Your Workers' Comp Costs Are Higher Than They Should Be

June is National Safety Month. Most employers acknowledge it with a poster in the break room or a safety memo to staff. A smaller number actually use it as the trigger it’s designed to be — a structured moment to evaluate what’s driving their workers’ compensation costs and what can be done about it before next renewal.

Let’s talk about that smaller group. Because right now, the workers’ comp market is genuinely rewarding them.

According to NCCI’s 2026 State of the Line data, written workers’ compensation premiums are expected to decrease by an average of 5% from 2025 to 2026 across NCCI-governed jurisdictions. The system combined ratio sits at 91% — a sign of strong underwriting profitability. In plain terms: the market has room to reward employers who manage their risk well. The question is whether your business is set up to capture that benefit or whether you’re subsidizing someone else’s claims.

What Your Experience Mod Is Actually Telling You

Your Experience Modification Rate (EMR) is the single most powerful lever in your workers’ compensation cost structure. Set by NCCI using three years of claims data, it compares your actual losses to what’s expected for a business of your type and size. An EMR of 1.0 is industry average. Below 1.0 and you’re paying less than average because you’ve earned it. Above 1.0 and you’re paying a surcharge.

Here’s what the math looks like in practice: an improvement from a 1.2 EMR to a 0.8 EMR on a $1 million workers’ comp premium saves $400,000 annually. That’s not a rounding error. That’s a real business outcome attached to safety culture, claims management, and loss prevention investment.

What most business owners don’t realize is that frequency, the number of claims, penalizes them more than severity in the EMR calculation. A cluster of small claims will spike your mod more than a single serious one. This means that a slip-and-fall culture, where minor injuries are common and unreported near-misses are routine, is actively inflating your premium year after year.

The Three Levers Most Businesses Aren’t Pulling

Return-to-Work Programs
Every day an injured employee is out of work costs money — both in indemnity payments and in the signal it sends to your experience modification. A structured return-to-work program that brings employees back to modified duty as quickly as medically appropriate dramatically reduces indemnity claim duration. According to the National Safety Council, businesses with active return-to-work programs consistently see lower average claim durations and measurable EMR improvement over a three-year window, yet many small and mid-sized employers still have no formal program in place.
Safety Culture, Not Safety Theater
There is a difference between posting OSHA-required signage and building a workplace where people actually report near-misses, correct hazards in real time, and feel accountable for each other’s safety. NSC’s 2026 National Safety Month theme — “Moving Safety Forward” — explicitly focuses on culture and forward-thinking systems, not compliance checkboxes. Employers who invest in supervisor safety training, incident investigation protocols, and workforce engagement on safety consistently outperform their class codes on EMR metrics.
Claims Management at First Report
The first 60 minutes after a workplace injury are among the most consequential in determining what that claim ultimately costs. Employers who have a clear first-report protocol — prompt medical direction to an occupational health provider, immediate supervisor documentation, and open communication with the injured worker — consistently close claims faster and at lower cost. BLS data consistently shows that claims left without structured management escalate in both duration and expense.

A Practical Action Checklist for June

Use National Safety Month as a structured prompt. Before June ends:

Pull your current EMR and review the claims driving it
Identify any frequency trends by department, shift, or job classification
Audit your return-to-work program or create one if none exists
Review your OSHA 300 log for near-misses and unreported minor injuries
Schedule a pre-renewal meeting with your broker to discuss EMR trajectory and loss control options

The market is working in your favor right now. Workers’ comp premiums are available at favorable rates for businesses that can demonstrate proactive risk management. That window won’t stay open indefinitely and the claims you have today are building the EMR you’ll be paying on three years from now.

Explore commercial insurance solutions and specialty programs built for employers who want to take control of their workers’ compensation costs. For workers’ compensation data, visit NCCI.com. For workplace safety resources, OSHA.gov offers free downloadable National Safety Month tools.

Ready to get your workers’ comp costs where they should be? The team at Tooher-Ferraris has been helping businesses build safer, more cost-effective programs since 1932. Contact us today to schedule a no-obligation consultation.

Employee Benefits

May 31, 2026

The Wellness Programs Actually Delivering Results for Employers in 2026

It’s Men’s Health Month, National Safety Month, and for many organizations, time for a mid-year benefits review. June has a way of bringing workforce wellbeing into focus, whether it’s part of your strategic plan or not.

That’s actually an opportunity. The conversation around employee wellness in 2026 is more sophisticated, data-driven, and closely tied to business performance than ever before. Employers achieving the strongest results aren’t simply offering wellness programs. They’re designing initiatives around proven strategies and evidence-based practices that improve employee health, engagement, productivity, and retention.

What the Data Is Telling Us

The National Safety Council, which marks its 30th anniversary of National Safety Month this June, frames workforce wellbeing as inseparable from safety culture. That framing matters. According to the CDC’s NIOSH Total Worker Health framework, organizations that integrate physical safety, mental health support, and preventive care into a unified approach consistently outperform those running siloed programs.

The Business Group on Health’s 2026 Employer Health Care Strategy Survey found that higher utilization of mental and behavioral health services is now one of the top drivers of health plan cost increases. Employers who are staying ahead of that curve are doing so by expanding access, not by limiting it.

Behavioral Health Integration: The Biggest Shift

The wellness programs delivering results in 2026 treat behavioral health as a core benefit, not an add-on. That means telehealth mental health access with realistic appointment availability, manager training to recognize and respond to burnout, and EAP vendors whose utilization rates are actually tracked and reviewed. Wellness and population health management programs designed with this in mind look very different from a gym discount and a biometric screening.

Employers who’ve moved in this direction are seeing downstream benefits in reduced absenteeism, better engagement scores, and lower long-term health costs. Behavioral health conditions left unaddressed are expensive. Early access and reduced stigma around seeking help are among the highest-ROI investments a benefits strategy can make.

Preventive Care Incentives That Actually Change Behavior

The most effective employer wellness programs in 2026 use incentive design thoughtfully. Participation-based incentives, tied to completing a health risk assessment, scheduling an annual physical, or engaging with a chronic condition management program, are outperforming outcome-based models in terms of employee acceptance and sustainable engagement.

For employers with self-funded or level-funded plans, the ROI case is direct. Every avoided ER visit, every early-caught chronic condition, every employee managing their diabetes effectively is a real dollar figure in the claims data. Data analytics and benchmarking tools now make it possible to connect wellness program participation to actual plan utilization trends giving HR leaders concrete evidence for program investment decisions.

Making It Work for a Mid-Size Workforce

You don’t need a Fortune 500 budget to build a wellness program that delivers results. Some of the most effective mid-size employer programs are built on three things: a behavioral health-forward EAP, a preventive care incentive tied to the health plan design, and a communication strategy that normalizes using the benefits available. Employee benefits strategy and consulting support helps employers design programs proportionate to their workforce size and budget without overbuilding or underdelivering.

This June, the conversation about wellness is worth having with intention. The employers investing in the right programs today are building healthier, more engaged workforces and managing costs better because of it.

Ready to build a wellness strategy that delivers real results? The team at Tooher-Ferraris has been helping businesses strengthen their benefits programs since 1932. Contact us today to schedule a no-obligation consultation.

External Sources: CDC NIOSH Total Worker Health | National Safety Council — National Safety Month

Business Insurance

May 30, 2026

7 Workers’ Comp Cost-Control Strategies Every Growing Contractor Should Know

Here’s a number worth knowing: the 2025 workers’ compensation combined ratio came in at 91%, according to NCCI’s 2026 State of the Line report — the twelfth consecutive year of underwriting profitability in the line. For contractors, that translates to one of the most stable WC markets in recent memory, with NCCI filing rate decreases in multiple states and most construction operators seeing flat-to-modest increases at renewal.

But stability isn’t the same as free. Your experience modification rate is being built right now, claim by claim, and whatever happens on your job sites this year will follow your program for the next three renewal cycles. The contractors who use a favorable market to tighten their cost-control disciplines are the ones who stay in good shape when the market eventually shifts. Here are seven strategies that make a measurable difference.

1. Understand Your Experience Mod and What’s Driving It

Your EMR isn’t just a number on your policy — it’s a direct function of your actual losses versus expected losses for employers of your size and class. Most contractors know their mod. Few have ever had someone walk them through exactly which claims are driving it. Request a detailed loss run from your carrier and review the open reserves on claims you may have considered closed. Unreserved or over-reserved claims inflate your mod even when the injury has resolved.

2. Build a Formal Return-to-Work Program

This is the single highest-ROI investment in workers’ comp cost control. According to OSHA research, injured workers who return to modified duty within the first two weeks of an injury have significantly lower total claim costs and faster full-recovery timelines than those who remain on full disability. A written RTW program with defined modified-duty job descriptions signals to carriers that you manage claims actively, not reactively.

3. Audit Your Payroll Classifications Regularly

Misclassification is more common than most contractors realize, and it runs in both directions. Workers classified under a higher-rated code than their actual duties warrant are generating unnecessary premium. As your business grows and roles evolve, annual classification audits with your broker can surface meaningful savings or protect you from an audit adjustment you didn’t see coming.

4. Prequalify Subcontractors on Insurance, Not Just Price

Every uninsured or underinsured subcontractor is a potential statutory employer exposure. If a sub’s worker is injured and their carrier denies the claim — or their limits are exhausted — your WC program may be the backstop. Prequalifying subs on their workers’ comp carrier, limits, and EMR before awarding work is a direct cost-control measure, not an administrative nicety.

5. Implement a Documented Safety Program — Not a Generic One

Carriers reward contractors with credible, site-specific safety documentation at renewal. A generic safety manual downloaded from the internet does not move the needle. A documented program with signed employee training records, incident investigation reports, corrective action logs, and toolbox talk attendance sheets demonstrates a culture of safety that underwriters can price. The NSC’s June National Safety Month framework, organized around continuous improvement, employee engagement, roadway safety, and wellbeing, is a useful structure for formalizing what many contractors already do informally.

6. Report Claims Immediately and Stay Involved

Late claim reporting is one of the most expensive mistakes in workers’ comp management. Claims reported within 24 hours have consistently lower ultimate costs than those reported days or weeks after an incident, because early intervention enables proper medical management and limits the window for claim escalation. Once a claim is reported, stay engaged — know the adjuster, understand the reserve, and confirm that a return-to-work plan is in motion.

7. Review Your Program With a Broker Who Knows Construction

Workers’ comp is not a commodity purchase. The difference between a broker who shops your program to the standard market and one who benchmarks your program against your peers, analyzes your mod trajectory, and structures a renewal narrative around your safety investments is substantial. For contractors managing complex risk profiles, captive insurance solutions may also be worth exploring as an alternative to the standard market. Learn more about how commercial insurance for contractors is structured to address the unique cost drivers in construction.

Ready to take control of your workers’ comp program before the next renewal? The team at Tooher-Ferraris has been helping construction businesses manage their risk and reduce their costs since 1932. Contact us today to schedule a no-obligation consultation.

Employee Benefits

May 29, 2026

The Real Reason Your Health Plan Costs Keep Climbing — And the One Lever Most HR Leaders Never Pull

Health costs are projected to rise 9.5% per employee in 2026, according to Aon’s annual health survey. Most employers find out what that means for their budget at renewal — sitting across from a carrier with a thick actuarial deck and very little room to negotiate. The employers who are navigating this environment well didn’t get lucky. They came to that table differently.

The conversation about rising costs tends to start and end with pharmacy, specifically GLP-1 weight-loss medications. And yes, pharmacy is a real pressure point. But focusing exclusively on one drug class misses the broader picture, and it puts HR leaders in a reactive posture when the data to be proactive has been available to them all along.

What’s Actually Driving the Increase

The 2026 Business Group on Health Employer Health Care Strategy Survey identified three compounding cost drivers: the rise of obesity treatments, increased cancer prevalence among plan populations, and higher utilization of mental and behavioral health services. These aren’t temporary spikes. They reflect shifts in workforce demographics and healthcare utilization patterns that will persist well beyond this renewal cycle.

High-cost claimants, individuals with claims exceeding $100,000 in a single plan year, are the single largest variable in a mid-size employer’s annual trend. A plan covering 150 employees can absorb routine utilization comfortably. One catastrophic claim from a cancer diagnosis or complex surgical event can move the renewal number by 15 to 20 percent on its own. For employers on fully insured plans, that exposure lands directly on their premium. For those on self-funded or level-funded arrangements, it flows through stop-loss which is why stop-loss structure and attachment points deserve as much attention as the plan design itself.

The Lever Most Employers Aren’t Pulling

Here’s what separates the employers who consistently achieve better renewal outcomes: they use their own claims data strategically, not reactively. Data analytics and benchmarking give HR leaders the ability to see — before renewal — where their claims dollars are going, which claimant segments are driving trend, how their plan performs against peer benchmarks, and where plan design changes could reduce unnecessary utilization without reducing the value of benefits to employees.

According to SHRM’s 2026 benefits research, employers who actively use claims analytics in their renewal strategy consistently outperform those who rely on carrier-provided summaries alone. The difference isn’t access to data. Most employers have more data than they realize. The difference is how that data is organized and brought into the conversation.

A well-run employee benefits strategy and consulting process starts with claims review four to six months before renewal, not four to six weeks. It maps high-cost claimant activity, flags pharmacy utilization patterns, benchmarks deductibles and cost-sharing against comparable employer groups and identifies whether current stop-loss attachment points still reflect the plan’s actual risk profile.

What This Looks Like in Practice

Employers who go into renewal with their claims data already organized aren’t just better negotiators, they’re making better decisions. They’re asking the right questions about network performance, evaluating whether their current carrier relationship is still the best fit, and building a benefits strategy that balances cost containment with the employee experience. The employee benefits services model at Tooher-Ferraris is built around exactly this kind of proactive, data-informed partnership.

The employers winning in 2026 aren’t reacting to the market. They’re shaping their outcomes ahead of it.

Ready to take a closer look at what your claims data is telling you? The team at Tooher-Ferraris has been helping businesses build stronger benefits strategies since 1932. Contact us today to schedule a no-obligation consultation.

External Sources: Aon 2026 Health Survey | Business Group on Health 2026 Employer Survey

Trusted By

Industry Leader Since

Serving Customers In

Why Your Workers’ Comp Costs Are Higher Than They Should Be