Data Analytics & Benchmarking

When you think about pollution liability, you might picture oil refineries or chemical plants — not earthmovers and grading contractors. But the reality is that heavy construction operations often carry significant pollution exposures, many of which are not covered by standard Commercial General Liability (CGL) policies.

For excavation contractors, road builders, demolition firms, or any business disturbing soil, pollution risks can be costly and complicated. One accidental spill or a hidden contaminant can trigger third-party lawsuits, regulatory fines, and cleanup costs that could sink a project.

At Tooher-Ferraris Insurance Group, we help contractors and developers understand how to protect themselves from these hidden risks. Let’s break down why CGL pollution exclusions matter, when to consider Contractors Pollution Liability (CPL), and how site-specific policies can safeguard your business.

Why Heavy Construction Has Pollution Risks

In the heavy construction world, “pollution” can come from unexpected places:

• Excavation: Unearthing old fuel tanks, asbestos, or contaminated soil.
• Equipment leaks: Hydraulic fluid, fuel spills, or oil leaks from heavy machinery.
• Stormwater runoff: Sediment and pollutants entering local waterways.
• Demolition debris: Releasing hazardous materials like lead or PCBs.

Even if your crews follow strict environmental protocols, accidents happen — and the cleanup costs can be staggering.

Why CGL Pollution Exclusions Matter

Most contractors carry a Commercial General Liability policy that protects them against bodily injury, property damage, and related legal costs. But here’s the catch: standard CGL policies almost always contain a total or absolute pollution exclusion.

What does that mean?
If your work unintentionally releases a pollutant that causes third-party damage — say, contaminating a nearby river — your CGL carrier can deny the claim.

And these exclusions aren’t always obvious. Many policies define “pollutants” broadly to include anything from chemicals to smoke or vapor. The result? Contractors who think they’re covered for an accident may find out too late that they’re on the hook for environmental damage.

Real-World Example
Picture this:
A grading contractor unknowingly uncovers contaminated soil while excavating for a new development. The soil is transported off-site but spills along the way, contaminating nearby land. The state issues an environmental cleanup order and third parties sue for property damage.

The contractor files a claim with their CGL carrier — only to have it denied due to the pollution exclusion.

When to Consider Contractors Pollution Liability (CPL)

A Contractors Pollution Liability (CPL) policy can fill these dangerous gaps. CPL insurance is designed specifically to cover:

• Third-party bodily injury or property damage from pollution conditions.
• Cleanup costs, legal defense, and crisis management expenses.
• Both sudden and gradual pollution incidents.
• Work performed by you or your subcontractors.

Who should consider CPL?

Any contractor whose operations could disturb existing contaminants or create new exposures should look at pollution liability coverage. This includes:

• Excavation and grading contractors
• Road and bridge builders
• Demolition contractors
• Utility contractors
• General contractors overseeing complex sites

Site-Specific Pollution Liability

Sometimes, one project carries unique pollution risks — like working on a brownfield site or near sensitive ecosystems. In these cases, a site-specific pollution liability policy can be the better solution.

Site-specific coverage protects the project owner, general contractor, and other stakeholders for known and unknown conditions related to that site. Many lenders and project owners now require these policies as part of their risk management program.

Policy Best Practices

If you’re considering pollution coverage, keep these tips in mind:

Review Contract Requirements:
Many public and private projects require proof of CPL. Don’t wait until bid day to discover you’re missing coverage.

Assess Subcontractor Risk:
A subcontractor’s pollution mishap can still land you in court. Make sure subs carry appropriate CPL limits — and track certificates carefully.

Work with an Expert Broker:
Pollution coverage can vary widely between carriers. Work with a broker who understands environmental risks and can negotiate the right endorsements for your operations.

Protect Your Projects — and Your Balance Sheet

Heavy construction is challenging enough without unexpected environmental liabilities draining your resources. With tight profit margins and strict regulatory oversight, one uncovered pollution event can do lasting damage to your bottom line and reputation.

Tooher-Ferraris Insurance Group helps contractors assess their real exposures, find hidden coverage gaps, and implement risk transfer solutions that protect them in the field and in the boardroom.

Stay Covered and Compliant

Do you know what your CGL actually excludes? Let’s find out together. Connect with a Tooher-Ferraris advisor today to review your pollution exposures and see if Contractors Pollution Liability or site-specific coverage makes sense for your projects.

Artificial intelligence (AI) and automation are revolutionizing the construction industry. Drones survey sites faster than ever, autonomous bulldozers grade terrain with precision, and AI-powered software helps teams coordinate complex projects in real time. While these advances boost productivity, they also introduce new risks — and raise important questions about how construction companies protect themselves through insurance.

At Tooher-Ferraris Insurance Group, we work with contractors, builders, and developers to navigate these emerging exposures. In this article, we’ll explore how autonomous equipment impacts your general liability and workers’ compensation programs — and why reviewing policy language for new technologies is essential.

Autonomous Equipment: A Double-Edged Sword

Automation promises safer sites by reducing human error and keeping workers out of hazardous conditions. For example, an autonomous excavator can dig a trench without putting an operator at risk of cave-ins or contact with underground utilities. However, these machines don’t eliminate accidents — they change how they happen.

Who’s at fault if an autonomous crane malfunctions and damages a nearby property? What if a site worker is struck by a driverless haul truck? Contractors, equipment manufacturers, software developers, and project owners could all be pulled into complex claims. Liability may be less clear-cut than with traditional human error.

Impact on General Liability

1. Bodily Injury and Property Damage

A standard Commercial General Liability (CGL) policy covers bodily injury or property damage arising from your operations. But with AI-driven equipment, questions can arise:

• Was the damage due to an equipment defect or an operator’s misuse?
• Does the subcontractor agreement properly transfer liability?
• If an AI system “learns” new behaviors, who’s responsible for its actions?

Insurers may scrutinize whether autonomous equipment was properly maintained, calibrated, and monitored. Contractors need to ensure maintenance logs and software updates are documented — and that contracts with technology providers clearly define responsibility.

2. Product Liability Exposures

If you own or modify autonomous equipment, you may be considered part of the “product chain,” exposing you to product liability claims. Traditional CGL policies may not fully cover this risk if they exclude product failures or don’t contemplate software errors that lead to damage.

Impact on Workers’ Compensation

AI and robotics aim to reduce manual labor injuries — one of the biggest drivers of workers’ comp costs. Fewer repetitive motion injuries and less exposure to dangerous tasks are clear benefits.

However, the introduction of autonomous machinery can create new hazards:

• Workers might not fully understand how to interact with robotic systems.
• “Human-robot interaction” injuries, like being struck by a self-driving loader, can lead to unique claims scenarios.

While your workers’ comp policy will generally respond to employee injuries, insurers may want to see robust training programs and safety protocols for working alongside automated systems.

Policy Language Considerations for New Tech

One of the biggest pitfalls for contractors embracing automation is assuming their existing insurance policies automatically adapt to new exposures. Here are three key areas to review with your broker or risk advisor:

• Definitions of “Covered Operations”:
  • Does your policy clearly define your work, including any ownership or operation of autonomous equipment? An outdated description could create a gap.
• Exclusions for Cyber or Tech Failures:
  • Many CGL and property policies contain exclusions for damage caused by software failure, cyberattacks, or programming errors. If an autonomous machine is hacked or its AI system malfunctions, you could find your claim denied. Consider stand-alone cyber coverage or technology E&O if you’re deeply invested in smart equipment.
• Contractual Risk Transfer:
  • When partnering with equipment manufacturers, software vendors, or subcontractors, contracts should clearly outline who assumes responsibility for malfunctions or misuse. Well-crafted additional insured and indemnification clauses can help protect you from unexpected losses.

Future-Proof Your Risk Management

AI and automation will only continue to evolve on construction sites. Forward-thinking contractors should not only invest in safety training and robust maintenance but also work with insurance partners who understand how to adapt coverage to modern risks.

At Tooher-Ferraris Insurance Group, we help our construction clients stay ahead of emerging liabilities. From reviewing your general liability and workers’ comp policies to negotiating endorsements that address new technologies, we’re here to ensure your coverage grows with your business.

Stay Ahead of the Curve

Is your construction company prepared for the new era of smart job sites? Connect with a Tooher-Ferraris advisor today to review your insurance program and protect your business from the evolving risks of AI and automation.