Why Fiduciary Liability Insurance is Important

Fiduciaries, such as company executives, HR professionals, or third-party administrators, oversee employee benefit plans, including retirement and health plans. If a fiduciary fails to act in the best interests of the plan participants—whether through negligence, error, or omission—they can face significant legal consequences. Fiduciary Liability Insurance covers these risks, protecting both the fiduciaries and the company from financial loss.

Common Risks Covered

Mismanagement of Plan Assets

One of the most significant risks covered by Fiduciary Liability Insurance is the mismanagement of plan assets. Errors in managing investments or other assets can lead to substantial financial losses for plan participants, which can, in turn, result in legal claims against the fiduciary.

Failure to Follow Plan Documents

Fiduciaries are legally obligated to adhere to the guidelines set forth in plan documents. Deviating from these documents, whether intentional or accidental, can expose the fiduciary to legal action. Fiduciary Liability Insurance provides coverage for claims that arise from such failures, ensuring that fiduciaries are protected even in complex legal scenarios.

Errors in Enrollment or Disbursement

Mistakes made during employee enrollment in benefit plans or benefit disbursement can lead to negligence claims. These errors, whether due to oversight or misunderstanding, can be costly to resolve. Fiduciary Liability Insurance covers these risks, protecting against claims related to administrative errors in plan management.

How to Reduce Your Fiduciary Liability Risk

While Fiduciary Liability Insurance provides critical protection, adopting best practices can help minimize your risks:

  • Regularly review and update plan documents and policies
  • Provide fiduciary training for staff and committee members
  • Conduct periodic audits of plan operations and investments
  • Document all decisions and the rationale behind them

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the difference between Fiduciary Liability Insurance and Employee Benefits Liability Insurance?

Fiduciary Liability Insurance covers the legal liability of fiduciaries who manage employee benefit plans. In contrast, Employee Benefits Liability Insurance typically covers errors and omissions in the administration of employee benefits, such as incorrect enrollment or termination of benefits.

Does Fiduciary Liability Insurance cover ERISA penalties?

Yes, Fiduciary Liability Insurance often covers penalties arising from violations of ERISA, though it’s essential to check the policy specifics as coverage can vary.

Who is considered a fiduciary under ERISA?

Under ERISA, a fiduciary is anyone who exercises discretionary control or authority over a plan’s management, administration, or assets. This can include plan sponsors, trustees, and advisors.

What are common exclusions in a Fiduciary Liability Insurance policy?

Exclusions often include fraud, criminal acts, personal profit, and failure to collect contributions. It’s crucial to review the policy details to understand what is and isn’t covered.

How much Fiduciary Liability Insurance do I need?

The amount of coverage needed varies based on the size of the business, the number of employees, and the complexity of the benefits offered. A risk assessment can help determine the appropriate coverage amount.

Can Fiduciary Liability Insurance be customized?

Yes, policies can often be tailored to fit your business’s specific needs, including additional coverage options for specific risks.

Is Fiduciary Liability Insurance mandatory?

While not legally required, Fiduciary Liability Insurance is highly recommended for any business that manages employee benefit plans due to the potential for significant legal exposure.

How does Fiduciary Liability Insurance interact with other business insurance policies?

Fiduciary Liability Insurance works alongside other business policies, such as Directors and Officers (D&O) Insurance, to provide comprehensive protection. Coordinating coverage is important to avoid gaps.

What steps can I take to reduce the risk of fiduciary liability?

Implementing best practices, such as regular plan audits, adhering strictly to plan documents, and providing ongoing fiduciary training, can help mitigate risks and reduce the likelihood of claims.

How do I file a claim under a Fiduciary Liability Insurance policy?

To file a claim, notify your insurance provider as soon as you become aware of a potential issue. Provide all necessary documentation, including any correspondence related to the claim. The insurance provider will guide you through the claims process.

Protect Your Business with Fiduciary Liability Insurance.

Fiduciary Liability Insurance is a vital component of a comprehensive risk management strategy for any business offering employee benefit plans. It provides crucial protection against the financial and legal risks associated with fiduciary responsibilities, ensuring your business can operate with confidence and security.

Protect your business and your fiduciaries by investing in a Fiduciary Liability Insurance policy that meets your specific needs.

Contact Tooher-Ferraris Insurance Group today to learn more about our tailored insurance solutions and how we can help safeguard your company’s financial future.

Insights

March 20, 2025

Captive Risk Management: A Smarter Way to Take Control of Your Insurance Strategy

For many businesses, traditional general liability insurance and professional liability insurance offer essential protection—but they often come with limitations. Rising premiums, rigid policy terms, slow claims processes, and frustrating exclusions can leave companies feeling powerless. As organizations grow, so do their risks. Yet, conventional insurance often struggles to keep pace, offering little flexibility or control. […]

Read More
March 20, 2025

Specialty Drug Coverage: Managing the Fastest-Growing Cost in Employee Benefits

While employee benefits are always changing, one of the most significant challenges is the escalating cost of specialty drugs. These medications, designed to treat complex and chronic conditions like cancer, rheumatoid arthritis, and multiple sclerosis, are revolutionizing patient care. However, their high price tags are placing immense pressure on employer-sponsored health plans. Understanding the drivers […]

Read More
March 20, 2025

The Hidden Costs of a Bad Benefits Package: Why Retention Starts with the Right Offerings

Attracting and retaining top talent has become one of the most pressing challenges for employers. Gone are the days when offering a competitive salary alone was enough to secure long-term employee loyalty. Today’s workforce—especially younger generations—places equal, if not greater, value on the quality and variety of the benefits an employer provides. From health coverage […]

Read More
March 20, 2025

Embracing Agile HR: A Smarter Approach to Change Management in Today’s Workplace

In the current business climate, change is constant and often unpredictable. Shifting workforce expectations, evolving technologies, regulatory updates, and new competitive pressures reshape how organizations operate. Adaptability has become a non-negotiable skill for HR professionals responsible for supporting their workforce and driving organizational success. Traditional HR processes, often structured in rigid, step-by-step models, struggle to […]

Read More
March 20, 2025

Construction Bonds vs. Insurance: What Contractors Need to Know

Construction projects are large-scale, high-stakes undertakings that involve careful coordination of multiple moving parts—contractors, subcontractors, suppliers, project owners, lenders, and regulatory bodies, just to name a few. With so many players involved, and tight deadlines and budgets at play, there’s no shortage of risks that can threaten the project’s timeline, financial stability, or overall success. […]

Read More
March 20, 2025

Unveiling the Hidden Perils: Why Event Insurance is Non-Negotiable

Hosting an event—whether it’s a corporate conference, a community festival, or even a wedding—is an exciting yet expensive undertaking. While the focus is often on guest experience, logistics, and coordination, the reality is that behind every successful event lies a web of potential liabilities. These hidden risks can easily derail your plans, leaving you exposed […]

Read More
Skip to content document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() { var videos = document.querySelectorAll('video.wp-video-shortcode'); videos.forEach(function(video) { video.muted = true; }); });